Tag Archives: AVOIDING A PERMANENT ESTABLISHMENT

European Court Allows Google Ireland Billions in French Tax Avoidance

European Court allows Google billions in legitimate French tax avoidance.

European Court allows Google Ireland billions in legitimate French tax avoidance. Learn how this applies to your U.S. state income tax planning. 

The concepts in tax treaties are ancient and provide tremendous tax savings for internet businesses.  International  E-commerce businesses can follow this Google model and avoid taxes.

Additionally, this Google model works in avoiding state income taxes in the United States.

Today’s tax treaties are based on the ides of business from the days of hard assets businesses (factories, warehouses, office buildings).   By keeping these ancient concepts, tax treaties make legal tax avoidance is easy for an internet business and an e-commerce business. 

In the summer of 2017, the Paris Administrative Tribunal, the Court found that France could not charge Google Ireland $1.4 billion in taxes.   Google France had assisted Google Ireland in its advertising business.  However, Google Ireland’s advertising computers were in Ireland, and none were in France.

The Google victory was ruled on Ireland-France Tax Treaty (1968).  The victory reflects the flaw of the ancient permanent establishment concept found in the 2014 European Model Treaty and the American model treaty. 

Continue reading

Form 1120-F (U.S. Income Tax Return of a Foreign Corporation) covers three different taxes. Saving International Taxes Requires an International Tax Accountant.

Table of Contents

1. This blog tells you how to protect yourself from the U.S. courts and the IRS.
2. his blog is primarily about U.S.  international income taxation and the branch profits tax.
3. Two important international tax laws to watch.
4. Tax Planning for your Balance Sheet and the Branch Profits Tax.
5. Liability Of Corporate Agent in the USA.

6. You Must Timely File  Form 1120F to Claim Deductions or Credits.
7, Protective Filing of Form 1120F:  Smart International Tax Accounting.
8. What if only part of your U.S. income is U.S. business income?

This just might be the most important blog on international tax that you will ever read. Here is the problem for U.K., EU, Australian, New Zealand, and Canadian corporations with U.S. income.

The internet is full of stories of how the tax treaty permanent establishment article prevents the USA from taxing you.  What the stories don’t tell is that the U.S. Tax Court does not care about your tax treaty.

The U.S. Tax Court is part of the Government.  The Government wants your money.  It is that simple.  Okay, it’s not fair.  But they really  do not care.  This link discusses a few of these anti-tax treaty court cases.

This blog tells you how to protect yourself from the U.S. courts and the IRS.

Foreign corporations have income from U.S. sources are always required to file U.S. tax returns.
Three different taxes are on the form as follows:

  1. Foreign corporations must pay a 30 percent tax on income from U.S. sources not connected with a U.S. trade or business.
  2. Foreign corporations engaged in trade or business within the United States is subject to income tax, alternative minimum tax, and other taxes applicable to corporations on their taxable income.
  3. Foreign corps engaged in business within the U.S. must pay the branch profits tax.

This blog is primarily about U.S.  international income taxation and the branch profits tax.

A foreign corporation with a business in the United States at any time during the tax year or that has income from United States sources must file a return on Form 1120-F.  A foreign corporation with U.S. business income must file (I will explain why later in this blog) even though:

(1) It has no business income (that is income effectively connected with the conduct of a trade or business) in the United States,

(2) It has no income from U.S. sources  or

(3) Its revenues are exempt from income tax under a tax convention or any provision of the tax law.

Two important international tax laws to watch.

  1. If the foreign corporation has no gross income for the year, it is not required to complete the return. However, it must file a Form 1120F and attach a statement (I will explain why later in this blog) to the return indicating the nature of any tax treaty exclusions claimed and the amount of such exclusions to the extent these amounts are readily determinable.[1]  For example, if you believe that you have avoided having a permanent establishment, you need to explain why.  Here is more on court cases on permanent establishment).
  1. To claim tax deductions and credits,  the corporation must file an accurate tax return on time. If the return is not timely file, all of the expenses and costs of goods sold can never be deducted.  If the U.S. income of a foreign corporation includes income that is subject to a lower rate of tax under a treaty, it must attach a statement to its return explaining this and showing:

(a) The income and amounts of tax withheld,

(b) The names and post office addresses of withholding agents, and

(3) any other information required by the return form or its instructions.[2]

Tax Planning for your Balance Sheet and the Branch Profits Tax.

The foreign corporation may elect to limit the balance sheets and reconciliation of income to the U.S. business use assets, liability and equity and its other income from U.S. sources.[3]   The branch profits tax traces the U.S. business equity and debts.  Thus, the balance sheet is the IRS’s primary audit tool.   Reporting your worldwide assets is providing the IRS information that has little or no value.

TAX TIP: A foreign corporation that is not engaged in a trade or business in the United States it is not required to file a return when the U.S. withholding of tax at the source of its payments covers the taxes owed.   A matter of fact, the goal of U.S. withholding tax is eliminated U.S. tax compliance for the foreign person.

Liability Of Corporate Agent in the USA

A representative or agent of a foreign corporation must file a return for and pay the tax on the income coming within his control as representative.   The agent can include a related corporation or an individual.

You Must Timely File  Form 1120F to Claim Deductions or Credits

I can not say this too often. A foreign corporation must its return on time to take deductions and credits against its U.S. business income.[4]

However, the following deductions and credits are allowed even if such a return is not filed:

(1) the charitable deduction;

(2) the foreign tax credit passed through from mutual funds;

(3) the fuels tax credit; and

(4) The credit for income tax withheld.[5]  

Timely filed means the Form 1120-F is filed no later than 18 months after the due date of the current year’s return.  

But it is more complicated, and you must read this:  I know this next section is tricky.  So, please be patient.  However, if you need help, then just give me, Brian Dooley, CPA, MBT a call at 949-939-3414. 

When the return for  the prior year was not filed, the return for the current year must have been filed no later than the earlier:

  1. of the date which is 18 months after the deadline for filing the current year’s return, or
  2. the date, the IRS mails a letter to the foreign corporation advising it that the current year return has not been filed and no deductions may be claimed it.[6]

The IRS may waive these deadlines when the foreign corporation proves that:

  1. It acted “reasonably and in good faith”  in failing to file a U.S. income tax return (including a protective return), and
  2. cooperates in determining its income tax liability for the year for that the return was not filed.[7]  

 Protective Filing of Form 1120F:  Smart International Tax Accounting 

This is the smartest thing you can do as a foreign corporation.   The chances of an audit are low and the tax protection is high.  I have the rules below. 

A foreign corporation with limited activities in the United States that it believes does  not give rise to U.S. gross business income should file a protective return.  

A timely filed protective return preserves the right to receive the tax savings  of the deductions and credits if it is later determined that the foreign corporation did have a U.S. business.  

Here is the very good news:  On that timely filed protective return, the foreign corporation is not required to report any gross income taxable income and thus pays no net income tax or branch profits tax.  

However, do not forget to attached a statement indicating that the return is being filed as a protective return and to check the box on the Form 1120F.  Also, you must include your tax treaty disclosure IRS form. Be sure to attach the IRS tax treaty disclosure Form 8823, on this link.  

What if only part of your U.S. income is U.S. business income? 

If the foreign corporation determines that part of the activities is U.S. business gross income that U.S. business income and part are not, then the foreign corporation must timely file a return reporting the U.S. business gross income and deducting the related costs and expenses.  

Important: Also, the foreign corporation must attach a statement that the return is a protective return about the other activities.   The protective election ensures that it can deduct the related expenses if the IRS should disagree.  

The same procedure is available if the foreign corporation when if they initially believe that it has no U.S. tax liability due to a tax treaty.[8]  Be sure to attach the IRS tax treaty disclosure Form 8823, on this link

As discussed above, many foreign corporations believe that their home country tax treaty “permanent establishment” provisions protect them since they do not have an office in the U.S.  However, the U.S. courts treat almost any office (even an office owned by an agent or a related person) as a permanent establishment.  

Lastly, U.S. Department of the Treasury will guide you and provide you with a tax guarantee.  This is known as a private letter ruling.  Here is more information.

FOOTNOTES

  1. Section 1.6012-2(g)(1)(i).

If the foreign corporation with a place of business in the United States, the return must be filed by the 15th day of the third month after the end of the tax year.

[2] Reg. Section 1.6012-2(g)(1)(ii).

[3] Reg. Section 1.6012-2(g)(1)(iii).

[4] Code Section 882(c)(2).

[5] Reg. Section 1.882-4(a).

[6] Reg. Section 1.882-4(a)(2).

[7] Reg. Section 1.882- 4(a)(3).

[8] . Reg. Section 1.882-4(a)(3)(iv).

How to Prepare Form 1120F for a Foreign Corporation’s non-U.S. Business Income and Investment Income & Form 5471

Table of Contents to Foreign Corporation Tax Planning and Preparation for Form 1120F.  For Form 5471, please click on this link.

International tax planning has a thin line between non-business income and business income.

A foreign corporation pays a tax of 30 percent of the amount it receives from sources within the United States as investment income and sometimes compensation:1

The 30 percent tax does not apply to interest income on a “portfolio debt”  that a foreign corporation receives from U.S. sources.

Avoiding U.S. tax on Businesses Income with no Permanent Establishment. 

One part of the Form 1120-F to report and pay tax on U.S. source investment income and U.S. source income from the sale of property (including inventory).  When the foreign corporation does not file the U.S. Form 1120F, the IRS can at any time assess taxes.  The corporation will also lose its right to deduct expenses.

If you are not sure if Form 1120F is required, you can use the safe method of a protective filing.   If you need help, then please call me Brian Dooley, CPA, MBT at 949-939-3414.

International tax planning has a thin line between non-business income and business income.

This thin line decides which of two very different tax laws apply.  This blog is on the income that is not connected to a  U.S. office or “place of business”.

Sometimes this income is investment income and sometimes business income that is not connected to a U.S. business’s office or place of business.

A foreign corporation pays a tax of 30 percent of the amount it receives from sources within the United States as:

(1) interest (other than bank interest),  dividends, rents, salaries, wages, premiums, annuities, compensations, remunerations, and royalties,

(2) gains on the disposal of timber, coal or domestic iron ore with a retained economic interest;

(3) gains from the sale or exchange of patents, copyrights, secret processes and formulas, goodwill, trademarks, trade brands, franchises, and other like property, or of any interest in such property but only to the extent the gains are from payments that are contingent on the productivity, use, or disposition of the property or interest sold or exchanged.   The taxable portion is after recovery of your cost; and

(4) and other “fixed or determinable” annual or periodical gains, profits, and income (this is a “catch all” part of the tax law that rarely applies).

The gross income (income before expenses) is taxed a 30 percent.  Sometimes, a tax treaty may reduce this tax rate.

The 30 percent tax does not apply to interest income on a “portfolio debt”  that a foreign corporation receives from U.S. sources.

The purpose of the portfolio debt tax law is to allow the foreign investor to make loans to U.S. persons and avoid U.S. taxes.  Yes, the intent of the law is to avoid taxes.  The following is a summary of the type of debts.

(1) An unregistered obligation that is payable only outside the United States if the obligation is designed to be sold only to a non-U.S. person; and

(2) A registered obligation for which a statement is if the beneficial owner of the obligation is not a U.S. person.

The following types of interest cannot be portfolio debt interest:

(1) Contingent interest, such as interest payments that depend upon the income, profits, or assets of the debtor;

(2) Interest received by a bank on an extension of credit made under a loan agreement entered into in the ordinary course of its trade or business;

(3) Interest received by a 10-percent shareholder of the corporation paying the interest; and

(4) Interest received by a controlled foreign corporation from a related person.[1]

The other advantage is U.S. estate taxes.  Upon the death of a non-resident alien, portfolio debt is not included in his or her U.S. estate tax return.

Avoiding U.S. tax on Businesses Income with no Permanent Establishment.

Tax treaty corporations have a unique advantage.   They can earn U.S. business income and not pay U.S. taxes.

Here are some examples of international tax strategies.

Personal service income to U.S. customers

A British law firm has American customers.  They perform the services outside of the U.S.  However; they have an office in Los Angeles for administration and marketing.  Payments made by their American customers are deposited into a U.S. bank located in Los Angeles.

Their income is not subject to U.S. taxes.  You will note that the law firm has a permanent establishment in the U.S.  They did not try to avoid having a permanent establishment or even a place of business.

The tax planning is the international tax law on service income.  This income is sourced where the individual (or computer as in the example below) is located when the services are provided.

Web services to U.S. customers.

A Swiss business has an app that is used by both American businesses and European businesses.  The customer pays for the app pay watching commercials or by monthly subscription services.  The Swiss company maintains and office in Orange County, California for their American owners and directors.  The Swiss company does it banking in Newport Beach, California, and Geneva.

The Swiss businesses income is not subject to U.S. taxes.  Learn why on this link.

Sale of merchandise to Americans   

Sam, a Canadian citizen, has an investor visa and lives in Malibu, and his office is in the Santa Monica.   He owns a U.K. company that sales paddle boards via a U.K. website.  He is a director of the U.K. company.  He is also the sole shareholder.

The paddles are shipped directly from Canada using Federal Express ground shipping.  Title to the paddle board passes to the customer via the website in Canada. The income of the U.K. company is subject to U.S. taxes.   Sam must file form 5471.

FOOTNOTE

[1] Code Section 881(c).

How the IRS Taxes Australian, Canadians, U.K. and Europeans Companies and Citizens Doing Business In The United States

french tax, french tax planning, job loss.

French businesses are profiting by avoiding the VAT by manufacturing in the U.S.

This blog is for Australian, Canadain, U.K. and Western European companies and citizens planning to have a business in the U.S. or business income from U.S. customers.

The United States is courting U.K., Western European, Canadian and Australian citizens to move their businesses.  The U.S. doesn’t  have a VAT (value-added tax).  The absence of this tax gives a 25% increase in a company’s purchasing power (assuming a VAT of 20%) of inventory, machinery, and employees.  Business makes more money due to the additional working capital.   

Labor unions are weak in the U.S. Employee rights are limited compared to the U.K., the EU, and Australia.

This blog explains how citizens (and their companies) from a tax treaty country are taxed in the U.S.

Continue reading

What You Need to Know to Do Business in the United Kingdom

Saving taxes, United Kingdom claims U.S. LLC is a tax haven company.

Saving taxes with international tax planning in the UK

The U.K. is a fantastic European headquarters.  Of course, they left the EU and despite this, the U.K. is my first choice.   Both Switzerland and The Netherlands would like to be your headquarters.   But they are missing the tax infrastructures that best fits the American tax laws.

The Big Tax Strategies of the U.K. are:
1.   They treat the U.S. limited liability company (LLC) as a passthrough.  The U.K. is the only country that has the identical treatment as the United States.   The cornerstone of small business international tax planning is the foreign tax credit.  

The foreign tax credit is the method of avoiding double taxation.   For example, you earn a $1,000 in the U.K. and the tax is $2,000 (the U.K.  has a low tax rate).   The U.S. tax on the $1,000 is $3,900.   The $3,900 is reduced by the $1,000.

U.S.-U.K. Income Tax Treaty and the Friendship, Commerce and Navigation  (FCN) Treaty Tax Planning and Strategy

This is big.  You can use domestic (I prefer Nevada) LLC for your international business.  An early  1900 treaty (FCN) allows the LLC the same rights in the U.K. as a U.K. company.

The British Inland Revenue changed their regulations to match the IRS regulations regarding the American LLC.    This allows the income tax treaty’s permanent establishment clause to protect you from U.K. taxation.    While the foreign tax credit does mitigate U.K. taxes, it is nice to be exempt from taxation.

The U.S. LLC Without a U.K. permanent establishment is treated as if it was only doing business in the U.S.    As you read below, the word term that is vague is “office”.    When tax treaties were envisioned, an office would have staff completing orders along with a “place of management”.  With E-commerce websites placing orders, I suggest that the computer server is kept in the U.S. 
The term “permanent establishment” includes:
a) a place of management;
b) a branch;
c) an office;
d) a factory;
e) a workshop; and
f) a mine, an oil or gas well, a quarry, or any other place of extraction of natural
resources. 

The term “permanent  establishment” does not to include:
a) the use of facilities solely for the purpose of storage, display or delivery of
goods or merchandise belonging to the enterprise;
b) the maintenance of a stock of goods or merchandise belonging to the
enterprise solely for the purpose of storage, display or delivery;
c) the maintenance of a stock of goods or merchandise belonging to the
enterprise solely for the purpose of processing by another enterprise;
d) the maintenance of a fixed place of business solely for the purpose of
purchasing goods or merchandise, or of collecting information, for the enterprise;

Avoiding IRS Form 5471 Controlled Foreign Corporation

Form 5471 is a complex tax return.  CPA fees start at $5,000.  Next, tax planning for the controlled foreign corporation is tricky.   Even the best tax planners can miss the target.

Using the foreign tax credit to reduce your taxes is by far the best way.   When a domestic LLC is used you do not file the Form 5471.  Matter of fact, if you are the only owner, you do not file any IRS form.  The LLC  files a partnership return,  Form 1065, when more than one person owns the LLC.